God For a Day

Boxing Day is an interesting holiday, widely observed across what was once the British Empire. Generally held on December 26th, it is a day when the wealthy would traditionally give gifts to their employees or to people of lower social classes. More interestingly, the wealthy would often trade places with their household servants for a day.

What better way to observe this holiday than to trade places with the boss of all bosses? Let’s take a little time to just imagine trading places with God.

We’ll use the most common Christian view of God as omniscient (knowing everything), omnipotent (being able to do anything), and omnipresent (being everywhere at the same time).

The Great Fruit Debacle

In the beginning You create the heaven and the earth (Genesis 1:1). You go on to create everything according to the primitive conception of the world that the authors of Genesis held, and then you create it a second time in Genesis 2. In Genesis 2, you perform your first and possibly most evil act.

Like babies off a cliff

This story is like setting your two little babies near the edge of a cliff, telling them “don’t crawl off or you’ll die”, and then leaving them alone.

After saying this you just watch, silent and out of sight, while one of your older and more knowledgeable children goads them into crawling off the edge of the cliff one at a time and falling to their deaths. This would be an easy task since the babies couldn’t possibly understand the meaning of your words.

Once they’ve both fallen, then you go down to see their shattered bodies on the rocks beneath and you say “You stupid babies, I told you this would happen! Now that you finally understand what I already knew, I won’t let you live even though I could save you. In fact, I will make you suffer before I let you die. Better yet, I’ll make every living thing in the world suffer and die, and I’ll blame it all on you. Now go away.”

You create Adam, you create the Garden of Eden, and then you create “the tree of knowledge of good and evil”. You stick the tree right in the middle of the garden, and then you tell naive Adam (who can not yet know the meaning of good and evil) not to eat from that one tree or he will die.

Ignoring the fact that Adam could not have comprehended death in this deathless world, and the fact that he could not have understood the “evil” of disobeying your command, what possible reason could you have for putting this tree in the garden!? It could have gone outside of the garden, and it would never be a problem, or it could simply not exist, but you chose to put it there.

The only reasonable explanation for this is that you knew exactly what would happen, you intended Adam and Eve to eat the fruit, and you are as guilty of instigating this mess as a police officer entrapping a mentally challenged child. You knew what would happen, and you set up the circumstances to allow it to happen, and you never stepped in to prevent this outcome when the serpent tempted Eve.

Being omniscient and omnipresent you must have seen it, and being omnipotent you could have stopped it or at least reminded them not to eat the fruit, but you just sat there and watched them destroy the world with a bite of fruit.

You didn’t stop Eve when she put the fruit to her lips, and you didn’t stop Adam when she offered it to him. You didn’t forgive them or repair the damage, you became afraid of them and you set us all on the endless trail of horrible suffering and death that still plagues the world to this day, just because you were angry and afraid.

Not only did you punish the entire world forever for the mistakes of Adam and Eve, you set the whole thing up knowing exactly what would happen. If anyone is responsible for “the fall of man”, it is you.

Mmmm…Burning Flesh

Once you’ve kicked Adam and Eve out of Eden, Eve starts having babies and suffering through the painful childbirth you inflicted on her and all of her descendants (Genesis 4:1-2, 3:16). She has Cain and she has Abel.

The first thing worth mentioning that happens in their lives is that they each bring an offering to you.

Cain is a farmer, so he brings “the fruit of the ground”. Abel is a rancher and he brings you the fat little firstborn baby animals from his flocks.

Cain brings the products of his farm to you, probably burning them for you as is the later custom, but you are not impressed. You don’t seem to have told people yet that you prefer sacrifices that bleed, cry, fear and feel pain.

Abel soon finds this out though when he brings the innocent little baby animals and kills them and burns them all just for you. There’s no reason for him to slit the throat of that cute little lamb, there’s no need to bash in the head of the calf he’s just dragged away from its mother, no reason that is other than your desire for all kinds of animals to be killed and burned for you, apparently just because you like the smell (Genesis 8:21, Exodus 29:18, 25, 41, Leviticus 1:9, 13, 17, Numbers 28-29, etc.).

So you let them know you don’t like Cain’s sacrifice, but you sure are happy with Abel’s! After all there is nothing you love more than the smell of the burning flesh of animals needlessly killed just for you. It’s so great in fact that you spend more verses in the Bible talking about how burning flesh is “an aroma pleasing to the Lord” than you do about the creation of the entire world!

Cain just can’t understand this. He’s angry and confused because Abel’s offering made you happy and his didn’t. So what do you do? Do you clearly explain to him what you want and that you still love him and you’ll be happy when he comes back and kills and burns helpless baby animals for you? No, you say something cryptic about how he would be accepted if he did well and then you leave.

You don’t calm Cain down so he won’t do anything crazy, you don’t save Abel from being murdered by his brother, you just set up the conflict and watch it unfold. There seems to be a pattern here: You cause trouble, you watch it play out, and you punish whoever’s left standing.

So Cain goes out into the fields with his brother and talks to him, and then we’re not sure what happens. Maybe Cain is still just mad and already planned to kill his brother, or maybe Abel laughed at him because God didn’t like his sacrifice? Whatever the reason, Cain kills Abel.

Of course you show up at this point, late again, but being omniscient and omnipresent, you were hanging around and watching the whole thing anyway. So you get mad at Cain and you kick him out of the place that you kicked Adam and Eve out to, and Cain (the only living person yet mentioned in the Bible after Adam and Eve) runs off to live in Nod.

Apparently Adam and Eve had enough female children to go out and build the city of Nod, but you must have thought they were not worth mentioning in your Bible, probably because they were female and you view women more as chattel, the possessions of their fathers or husbands, than as valuable individuals (Genesis 19:1-8, Exodus 20:17, 21:4, 7-11, Numbers 5:11-31, 30:1-16, 31:17-18, Deuteronomy 20:14, 22:13-21, 22:28-29, Ephesians 5:22-24, Colossians 3:18, 1 Timothy 2:11-15, 1 Peter 3:1, etc.).

So Cain goes to Nod and takes a wife, who would also have to be his sister, and they start having sons. Eve has another son, Seth, to replace Abel, and Seth has a son to finish up Genesis Chapter 4. If any of them have daughters, apparently you don’t care.

Once again, in this second tragedy the Bible describes, you have instigated the whole thing and done nothing to prevent the tragic outcome, but you have still convinced people to believe that you did nothing wrong. Bravo God, bravo.

The Rest of the Bible

So far we have only covered the first couple of pages of the first book of the Bible, but you have already created the world and engineered its demise, as well as inciting one of only four humans in the world to murder one of the other three and then you just watch it happen.

After a long list of Adam’s descendants in chapter 5, in chapter 6 of Genesis there are already half-human half-angel hybrids roaming the land (Genesis 6:1-4), and you already regret creating people (6:5). You decide this was all a big mistake and you should wipe out all life on Earth (6:6-7) which you do in chapter 7. You only spare 8 people along with 2 of each other unclean species of animal and 7 of each clean one.

This means that you kill nearly every man, woman, child, infant, dog, cat, cow, sheep, elephant, frog, bird, beetle, tyrannosaurus rex and every other species that has ever lived on this planet. Even if we discount the deaths of millions upon millions of innocent animals, how many people do you kill here? Tens of thousands? Hundreds of thousands? Millions?

As soon as you’re done with Noah, in Genesis 11 you get scared that people building a tall tower will actually reach heaven, so you go down and change their languages so they can’t understand each other and you scatter them all over the world. At least you refrained from killing everyone for once, but that still isn’t nice, and isn’t all this fear unbecoming for an omniscient and omnipotent being?

The Bible goes on and on like this, book after book. You tell a Satan to torture Job, kill his whole family and take everything from him just to prove that he will still worship you. This is what the whole book of Job is about!

Here are just a few more of your many murders and commands to enslave, murder and massacre individuals, cities and even whole nations.

  • You command the Israelites to kill everyone in their way, every man, woman and child in many cases (Deuteronomy 3:1-7, Joshua 6:20-21, Judges 21:10-24, 1 Samuel 15:2-3, etc.).
  • You tell them to wage genocidal campaigns against the Babylonians, Amorites, Hittites, Perizzites, Canaanites, Hivites, and Jebusites (Jeremiah 50:21-22, Exodus 23:23).
  • You condone slavery (Exodus 21:1-11, Leviticus 25:44-46, etc.).
  • You ask Abraham to kill and burn his own son as a sacrifice to you (Genesis 22:1-18).
  • You kill 70,000 people because King David conducts a census (1 Chronicles 21:9-14).
  • You kill a baby for the sins of its father, again King David (2 Samuel 12:11-14).
  • You kill all of the firstborn sons in Egypt to convince the Pharaoh to let your people go, but you don’t hurt the Pharaoh himself (Exodus 12:29-30).

This is just a small sample of the horrors you perpetrate in the Bible. Are you ready to go back to your “sinful” human self yet?

What would you really do?

If you were God, what would you do with the world? Would you help, or hurt? Would you create and responsibly maintain an earthly paradise, or would you continually set people up to be hurt and killed and fail in the most horrible ways?

This little role reversal is done in a humorous way, but it is intended to make you think seriously. Religious apologists will always be able to come up with some twisted exegesis to explain away the horrors of the Bible, but if you carefully read the entire Bible and honestly ask yourself each time God says or does something, “would I think this was right and good if I did it?”, you will find yourself answering “no” a disturbingly large number of times.

This idea will be scoffed at by many Christians because “we can’t know the mind of God”, but even our limited minds can see problems in the words and deeds of the Bible’s god. These are problems that do not appear less severe to more intelligent observers, they only become more abhorrent and disturbing when we see them as being done by a god who knows everything about everything and can do anything he wants to do with the universe.

In this light, the god of the Bible is a monster.

This entry was posted in Articles and tagged by Kazz. Bookmark the permalink.

About Kazz

My name is Shawn Esplin and I am an advocate of Free Thought and general good sense and thought in general. To that end, I encourage people to seriously question the things that they have been taught, especially as children, because many of these things - religious and secular - are taken on faith until we actively choose to seriously examine them for ourselves.

8 thoughts on “God For a Day

  1. A few things:

    1. Your versions of Genesis 6 (angel/human hybrids!) is simply wrong
    2. You have made a fundamental mistake with the idea of a role reversal –
    the whole point is WE ARE NOT God, so it is simply not the same thing
    3. The reason you have such a problem with the judgments of YHWH is b/c
    you fail to take the reality and depth of human sin and evil seriously
    4. Even IF quote “the god of the Bible is a monster” in your view,
    that does not in and of itself mean He does not exist. So this is not even a proof.
    5. Some of this reminds me of Nietchzie when he said (and I paraphrase here):
    “If there was a God, how could I bear to not be him? Consequently, there is no God”

    These points may not convince you, per se, but I search for CLARITY
    when AGREEMENT is not an option

    vm

  2. I agree that this is not proof that there is no god, and I don’t intend it to be. Like I mentioned near the end, I expect the kind of criticism you brought up, but I don’t find it convincing.

    You can say “we don’t fully understand quantum physics, but God does”, I would have to say that if your concept of a god exists, that would be true.

    If you say on the other hand “we don’t understand why the murder of infants is sometimes a good thing, but God does”, I can’t swallow that one.

    If we say “we just can’t imagine the good reason that God has for it, but He does have one”, then we are basically saying that if we were more intelligent then we would see that sometimes murdering babies is good. Either that or “God can do whatever he wants because He’s God”, and either answer is in my opinion seriously flawed.

    You also say that I “fail to take the reality and depth of human sin seriously”, but it’s not that I don’t take the horrible things I see people doing seriously, but the “reality” of the religious concept of “sin” is not proven to be real, it is just your belief.

    When someone enslaves another person and beats them, I take that seriously. When someone brutally rapes a young unmarried woman, the depth of the crime is not lost on me. When someone anally electrocutes dozens of tiny animals to make a fur coat, I see the sickness more than most.

    When someone works on the Sabbath day though, or worships the wrong god, or lies to prevent someone from being murdered, the “reality and depth of human sin and evil” in these cases is lost on me.

    The god of the Bible on the other hand would only consider the second group wrong, and all equally worthy of eternal punishment, but the first group gets a slap on the wrist if anything.

    As for the angel/human hybrids, I understand that this is not your view of the Nephilim, but it is not “simply wrong”. It is the view held by many Christians, and I believe most Jews as well.

    I do plan to do further research on the Nephilim and the meaning of “sons of God” in the Bible, but I don’t feel that I’m misleading people by using such a widely held interpretation of this passage. Especially since it seems most likely to be the intended meaning of the passage based on my research so far.

    By the way, although when I made my Nephilim card I used a version of the Bible that talked about marriage in Genesis 6:2 (I chose that version because it used Nephilim rather than Giants or something else misleading), I have also looked at “Young’s Literal Translation” which at least appears to me not to necessarily be about marriage.

    “and sons of God see the daughters of men that they [are] fair, and they take to themselves women of all whom they have chosen.”

    I don’t know the original Hebrew, but it still seems to me that even the demon or fallen angel/human hybrid camp might still have a leg to stand on if that isn’t explicitly referring to marriage.

    Anyway, again I don’t expect this post to convince anyone that gods don’t exist, but I do hope that just scratching the surface of these problems like I did makes people think about what kind of god the Bible portrays, and about whether or not that kind of god makes sense, and if they’re Christian, whether or not that fits with their own concept of God.

    Maybe they’ll decide that this god of senseless cruelty is theirs, but maybe it will lead to further questioning of the Bible. I can only present my own ideas and the facts as I understand them, and beyond that people have to think for themselves and make up their own minds, or let someone else think for them (which I wish people wouldn’t do).

  3. In response to the angel hybrids topic. I got my tanakh out… and here’s what it says english wise.

    Genesis 6:2 – the divine beings(a) saw how beautiful the daughters of men were and took wives from among those that pleased them.
    (a) alternate translation – the sons of god

    Genesis 6:4 – It was then, and later too, that the Nephilim appeared on earth – when the divine beings cohabited with the daughters of men, who bore them offspring. They were the heroes of old, the men of renown.

    Using The New JPS Translation, Second edition (1999)

    Anyways onto other things. I must run cause I have cookies that will burn if I do not remove them. Kazz, feel free to ask me for my tanakh verses for the “Old” Testament

  4. I find Kazz’s God For A Day discourse illuminating and right on the money. The abusive, senseless, and monster-like behavior of the bible’s god is self-evident and, like the rest of it all, makes no sense whatever.
    Find this Blog has been (for me) better than faith indeed!
    FrankC

  5. I like this post. Exactly from the point of view of “does this God make any sense”. I believe in a god, but he has little or nothing to do with the Christian God, nor any other god I know of. Not long ago I came to think that God has narcissistic personality disorder, and blogged about it. (Link with the reply.) So yeah, I think there are more options to choose from than the Christian God or no god at all.

  6. i don’t think that we critized something that very human expression so i think it good to understand our own viewpoint of experience an

  7. Interesting, thought provoking post. The bible was written in the bronze age during a superstitious and barbarous age. The more I investigate bible verses, the more transparent it is that this book apparently came from the mind of a divine god and it seems incredulous that this is actually a perceived legitimate religion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>