Gods and Gangs: Indoctrinating the Vulnerable

I just watched a documentary on the National Geographic Channel called LA Gang Wars about the gangs in the Compton area in Los Angeles, and it made me think about faith and indoctrination. I don’t want anyone to think that I am equating church life with gang life, but when you look at why people join or become more involved in a church or a gang, the psychology seems to be very similar.

I’m not a psychologist, and I could be misinterpreting or missing things, but these seem to be some of the biggest motivating factors for people becoming involved in either a church or a gang.

  • People want answers.
  • People want easier lives.
  • People want somewhere to turn when they have problems.
  • People look for these things where they’ve been taught to look for them.

Let’s break these down a little more.

People want answers.

Everyone has questions, whether it’s something as philosophical as “Why does the universe exist?” or something as simple as “Where will I get my next meal?” Religions try to deal with the more complicated issues, but for a kid who falls asleep to the sounds of gunfire and sirens every night, the kind of question that commands his attention may be “Should I shoot someone from another neighborhood who walks by my house?” Those are the kinds of questions that gangs answer.

Either way, people are looking for the answers they think they need, and someone is always willing to give them their own kind of answers, but they are not always the right ones.

People want easier lives.

When people have hard lives, they have all the more reason to want their lives to be easier. This is one reason that missionaries have more success in poor areas with a lot of problems than in more wealthy and healthy areas.

While religion doesn’t make people’s lives easier by allowing them to work less or to have more money, it does provide things like hope, peace of mind and community. Gangs provide many of these things and often more.

Gangs provide a sense of community, but one that includes the “us vs them” mentality that can keep a member in and make them do almost anything for the group. Gangs provide a kind of peace of mind by simplifying their lives down to the most basic “kill or be killed” mentality. No remorse, just do what you have to do to survive, and take out “the enemy” whenever, wherever, and however you can.

If you were living in a war zone, would you want to work at a store for low pay, unarmed and expecting that at any time someone may come in and rob or kill you? Or, would you want to make relatively large amounts of money hanging out with your friends, feeling safer armed and with a group of people who would kill for you? Legality and morality doesn’t matter at that point. What matters is the gang and your position within that “community”.

Sure, most of us would say “Just leave the area, that would make your life easier!”, but many present or future gang members don’t feel like that is an option, and others can’t even imagine life any other way.

People want somewhere to turn when they have problems.

Most people have their families to lean on in hard times, and many will also turn to whatever god(s) they believe in, which is one of religion’s strongest draws. The same need is also one of a gang’s strongest draws.

A very large percentage of gang members have absent parents, and many of them have already lost family members to gang violence. Far from turning them away from gangs, the desire for parental figures or revenge drives many people, even young children, right into the arms of the gangs that cost their family members their lives or freedom.

A seven year old is unlikely to go out and start killing people on his own, but if his gangbanging father was killed by a rival crew, and a leader in his father’s gang takes the kid under his wing, he’s going to find the comfort he’s looking for, but he’s also going to find violence, crime and probably a life-long blood-feud against the rival gang. He could easily be a killer long before he could be a father to the gang’s next generation.

People look for these things where they’ve been taught to look for them.

Who are the easiest people to indoctrinate?

Children.

Most children are born with an inquisitive nature and a willingness to accept what they are taught, either explicitly or by example. This applies just as much to relatively harmless lies (“there is a fairy who comes and buys your teeth if you put them under your pillow”), and even very harmful lies (“there is a man in the sky watching everything you do and he’ll punish you for eternity if you don’t do exactly what we say he wants you to do” or “anyone who talks to the police deserves to die”), as it does to truth.

Children are very often intentionally indoctrinated early with the ideas of their parents’ religions, but the minds of children with gang members in their families, or even children just living in areas with high levels of gang activity, are being filled with the ideas and ideals of gang life, for the most part unintentionally.

The outcome is still the same. If you see your parents face Mecca and pray to Allah 5 times a day, you will probably become a Muslim. If you grow up surrounded by violence and vengeance and then see your gangbanging older brother shot down in the street, you will probably take his place and go looking for revenge.

We owe it to our children, and to the rest of the world, to instill in them the best of what we have learned as adults who are capable of more rational and informed thought. We also owe it to them to protect them as much as we can from our unfounded biases and beliefs.

Teaching children that fire will burn them is important. Teaching them that “those people are lazy and useless and should be sent back where they came from” is not.

“Saint” Francis Xavier knew what he was talking about when he said “Give me the children until they are seven and anyone may have them afterwards.” The early years of a person’s life will deeply affect them until the day they die, and if they are taught the wrong things, that may be all too soon.

Children do not need to know that the gang from the next block should be killed on sight, and children do not need to know that bread can turn into the flesh of a god-man that people eat once a week. If either of those things is true, it should be just as true when they are old enough to consider the issues for themselves.

Mill Resistance – August 2008

July 26, 2008
8:00 pm
August 2, 2008
8:00 pm
August 9, 2008
8:00 pm
August 16, 2008
8:00 pm
August 23, 2008
8:00 pm
August 30, 2008
8:00 pm

What is the Mill Resistance?

If you’ve been on Mill this summer, you probably know that it’s been a bit slow, and often less fun and interesting than it was in the spring, but that is going to change shortly.

Late August is when ASU’s classes start again, so in a few weeks we should be back to full strength, and beyond as we gain more new recruits!

That is not to say that we shouldn’t bother until then. The times when things are a little less crazy give us a good chance to hone our skills and make plans for the future! If you haven’t been coming out and you’re considering it, now would be a good time to start.

Atheism

Download Atheism (PDF)

Atheism Tract - Side 1
Atheism Tract - Side 2

Side 1: Atheism – Definition

a-the-ism
[ey-thee-iz-uhm]

a lack of belief in the existence of God or gods

That is the entire meaning of atheism.

Atheism is not a religion, it is not a belief system.
Atheism is nothing sinister, and nothing to fear.
When it comes to Zeus, we are all atheists.

Side 2: But aren’t atheists bad people?

But aren’t atheists bad people?

Not any more than religious people are. Many people use "holy books" as moral guides, but as much as Christians want us to believe that the Bible is the world’s best guide to morality, it is clearly not.

We are actually programmed with a moral code by our genes and by the societies we live in. Adherence to the Bible is not an indicator of increased morality. In fact the US, the most religious developed country in the world, is far from being the most moral. For example, it has a murder rate over 10 times that of largely atheist Japan, and 2-10 times that of irreligious countries in Europe, with 8 of the 10 most murderous states in the US being in the more religious south, which also boasts the highest divorce rates.

Texas, one of the most religious states in the nation, has the largest percentage of its population in prison, despite having the highest execution rate. Higher than the next 6 states combined. The US, just 5% of the world’s population, has 25% of all prisoners. It has high rates of unwanted pregnancy and sexually transmitted disease, partly caused by religiously based "abstinence only" education.

Is this what we should expect from the last bastion of widespread fundimentalist Christianity in the developed world?

About:

So far this has been one of our most popular tracts. Atheists and even many agnostics like it because it delivers one of our most important messages: Religious people do not have a monopoly on morality. We non-believers are as likely as anyone to be good people.

The content is also very quickly clear to people taking it, and although some will immediately drop it when they read the word "atheism", more reasonable people will usually read at least the front and hopefully see the truth about us if they didn’t already know.

Be a Good Christian Hermaphrodite

Hermaphrodite Symbol

What does it mean to "Be a good Christian hermaphrodite"? How can we possibly know without consulting the Bible? Let’s do that now.

The Bible spends quite a bit of time talking about and legislating sex, and for many millions of people it is the single unquestionable source of perfect moral teachings. What then does the Bible say about the sexual relationships of intersexed people? Little to nothing.

This leaves the few Christians who even consider the question with a dilemma. "Do I try to find an answer hidden in other Bible verses, do I make up my own answers, or do I simply dodge the issue in a way that can’t be seen as sinful?"

While most seem to take the latter approach and ignore the issue or give meaningless answers, some of the more moderate Christians actually understand the issue and take a more reasonable approach, ignoring the "slippery slope" to homosexuality, and accepting gender reassignment surgery and sex with the opposite of the chosen gender.

Fundamentalist Christians on the other hand seem to have only one possible answer, as given by the infamous preacher "Brother Jed" to an intersexed friend of mine: Abstinence. He prescribed life long abstinence.

The reason that no other answer was viable for him is that he shares the common fundamentalist idea, which appears to be supported by the Bible, that homosexuality is a horrible sin. If a physically intersexed person is allowed to have sex with anyone then they would at least outwardly appear to be having homosexual sex, and there is no way a good queer-hating fundamentalist Christian could support such an "abomination".

Sister Pat, one of Brother Jed’s sidekicks, said that an intersexed person could get into heaven by "living as a good Christian Hermaphrodite", although what exactly this entails was never made clear. Brother Jed himself also opined that the reason some people are born intersexed is that their parents were bisexual.

Hermaphrodite Statue at the Louvre

Hermaphrodite at the Louvre

This shows a gross misunderstanding of genetics and sexuality, and basically punishes babies for their parents’ "sins" through the miracle of divine intervention. If these scapegoated children live their lives in complete devotion to God and abstain from (potentially homosexual) sex and all other sins to the best of their ability, will God, their omnipotent creator, perform the simple miracle of assigning them a singular, complete gender so they can then produce a family to worship him forever?

The answer seems to be no. Like the miraculous healing of amputees, miraculous sexual reassignment does not happen.

The reality is, like most people in general, many Christians do not know what actually causes people to be born intersexed, and they have just as little information about how these people should live their lives.

Intersexed individuals (formerly described as "hermaphrodites" from the Greek god Hermaphroditus who possessed both male and female physical traits) are those who are neither exclusively male nor exclusively female. They may have biological characteristics that are both male and female, expressing physical traits (phenotype) of one sex but possessing the sex chromosomes (genotype) of the other. Variations in physical expression occur, and it is possible that someone who appears physically "normal" is, in fact, intersexed due to their genetic makeup. The birth rate of all of these "hermaphrodites" is generally 1%, and while this sounds low, remember this is one out of every 100 births[1].

In most societies intersexed people have a hard enough time already without trying to live by the conflicting and often unrealistic expectations of Christians and their outdated and inadequate book.

The best an intersexed person can do is find what feels right, with the help of genetic testing and counseling if necessary, and with or without surgery just try to live life the best they can as the gender(s) that they feel they are.

1. Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersexuality

Never Stop Thinking

Should you stop thinking and just believe?

That’s what many people would like you to do.

Faith in gods and religious books like the Bible is easily shaken by the simple act of thinking objectively about your beliefs.

Many find justification for their hatred within their religious beliefs. Rather than follow this example, we should look for truth wherever we can find it. The Bible and other religious books contain good ideas, and we can incorporate them into our lives without believing in anything supernatural, and without blindly accepting the hate, lies and suffering they also support.

Consider some of the actions attributed to gods – things that our own “religious tracts” like to point out – that most people aren’t aware of. Then decide whether or not you can support these actions as the “works” of a loving, caring, omnipotent god.

Many don’t know about the more disturbing contents of their holy books, things their churches are unlikely to ever mention, but you can tell them.

Break that taboo; think for yourself!

We don’t need to justify ourselves with belief and faith.

Realize that it is okay for us to question people’s religious beliefs just like anything else. We don’t have to respect unfounded faith in the imaginary, and given many religious people’s plans to force their ideas on the rest of us, it is not safe to ignore them.

Check out the articles, books, tracts and forums available at Better Than Faith. Look for truth wherever you can find it, but please be skeptical, demand proof for extraordinary claims, and don’t let yourself be hoodwinked by charlatans.

Question your political and religious leaders. Question your parents. Question your teachers. Even question yourself.

Never stop thinking and you will find the truth for yourself.

Is THIS your God? – Bears

Download Is THIS your God? – Bears (PDF)

Is THIS your God? - Bears
Is THIS your God? - Bears

Side 1: Is THIS your God?

And he went up from thence unto Bethel: and as he was going up by the way, there came forth little children out of the city, and mocked him, and said unto him, Go up, thou bald head; go up, thou bald head.

And he turned back, and looked on them, and cursed them in the name of the LORD. And there came forth two she bears out of the wood, and tare forty and two children of them.

- 2 Kings 2:23-24 KJV

Side 2: Discussion

Do you believe in a god that sends bears to massacre children?

In this passage, a group of children tease the bald prophet Elisha. If he were the prophet of a kind and loving god, he would “turn the other cheek”, but instead he curses them, and his god sends bears to kill 42 of the kids.

This is a fine example of the cruelty and pettiness so often shown by the god of the Bible. Most Christians believe in a god of love and forgiveness, but the Bible’s god is a god of fear and vengeance.

Do you think this monster is worthy of praise? Do you think it even exists?

About:

This is the first in a series of tracts asking people to consider some of the actions attributed to their gods, especially things that most people aren’t aware of, and to decide whether or not they can support those actions or their perpetrator.

Most people don’t know about the more disturbing contents of their holy books, and their churches are unlikely to tell them, but you can tell them.